Search The Tattler

Showing posts with label The Emeryville Tattler. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Emeryville Tattler. Show all posts

Sunday, September 7, 2025

Emeryville Launched Novel Legal Effort to Silence the Tattler

City's Tattler "Communication Plan" Is Really A Non-Communication Plan 

By Mr X

Emeryville’s administration is attempting to muzzle the city’s independent news service, erecting roadblocks to news-gathering and threatening the publication’s editor with prosecution. 

Oddly echoing events playing out in Washington DC, local leaders have enacted an executive order barring the Tattler’s editor from any vocal or written interaction with any city employee. 

According to a 'communication plan' drafted by City Attorney John Kennedy, Tattler editor Brian Donahue may only communicate with city elected leaders, officials or employees during the ‘public comment’ period of city council meetings. Under state regulations, city officials, elected leaders and employees are all barred from addressing concerns raised during public comment. 

Kennedy, in a memo sent to the Tattler in October, describes the Editor’s news-gathering and reporting as "harassment," “aggression,” “threatening,” “intimidating,” and “hostile,” attempting to conjure a linguistic context for his actions. Exactly the types of terms the Administration in Washington has leveled at news outlets not offering fawning, supplicating coverage. 

A bizarre attempt by Kennedy to add gravitas by citing case law, undermines his own memo, and the constitutionality of his actions potentially resulting in financial liability for the City of Emeryville. One case, Minn. Bd. Commun. for Colleges v. Knight, 465 U.S. 271 (1984) concerns unrepresented groups attending meetings for unionized employees during contract negotiations, the other, L. F. v. Lake Wash. Sch. Dist. concerned an aggrieved parent and communications with the teachers of that parent’s children and school and district officials—not an entire city. Regardless, on-going bi-weekly meetings between the parent and school officials were established. 

While this effort to restrict and eventually destroy an independent voice in Emeryville plays out in court, perhaps the most troubling aspect is how closely local officials are adhering to and advancing President Trump’s effort to silence inconvenient voices. The Emeryville Tattler must be fairly effective.



Mr X, besides working for the Tattler, was a reporter for the Oakland Tribune and several other print
publications, two NPR affiliates in 
Northern California and received an Edward R Murrow award for his work covering wildfires in Northern California. 



Silencing journalism increases group think, stifles public participation and decreases critical thinking.


Wednesday, April 23, 2025

Priforce: Protect Press Freedom in Emeryville - Stand With Local Journalism

 Council Member Priforce Weighs In -


My Turn

Council Member Kalimah Priforce

The Tattler has always made itself available to all elected officials in Emeryville to use as a platform to reach out to the citizens for whatever reason they wish.  We call it 'My Turn'.  All electeds are always invited at any time to submit information in the public interest and the Tattler will post it verbatim.  Council member Priforce has requested a Tattler space in kind and we accommodate all Emeryville elected officials in this request.   This story submission was not suggested by the Tattler in any way. 


Protect Press Freedom in Emeryville—Stand with Local Journalism

By Council member Kalimah Priforce

Emeryville may be small, but we’ve always dreamed big—community kindness, safe and clean streets, mobility in our lives and on the road, and the power of everyday people - creating and innovating.

But none of that works without a free press - our collective voice.  Journalists like Brian Donahue of the Emeryville Tattler and local news hub, the E’ville Eye, shine a light where others won’t.  Whether you love his reporting or can’t stand it, Brian challenges our leaders to be honest.  And that’s something we all benefit from.

But today, that vital freedom—the right to know—is under attack.

For over 15 years, Mr Donahue has reported on Emeryville politics, exposing the stories that matter.  From toxic waste sites to addressing the genocide in Gaza, his annoying tenacity has rattled some powerful cages, and now those forces are striking back.

City Attorney John Kennedy is trying to silence him and the Emeryville Tattler — first with a "communication plan" barring city staff from speaking to him and threatening legal action just for asking questions outside public meetings to now pursuing a permanent restraining order against him.

It’s not unlike my own censure and sanction.  Both were pushed through during a time when Emeryville was without a permanent city manager—a vacuum where the city attorney had too much power from a majority of the city council and no one to rein him in.

This kind of overreach doesn’t just happen in closed sessions—it’s happening right here, out in the open. And it’s expensive: the city’s push for a restraining order against Mr Donahue has already cost us taxpayers over $50,000 and could easily double that when it's over. That's money that could be going to essential city services, alleviating rent burdens, or our public arts.

If we had a public ethics commission watching over City Hall, these abuses of power would be prevented.

And this isn’t the first time Emeryville has battled corruption.  In the 1920s, Chief Justice Earl Warren called us “the Rottenest City on the Pacific Coast” because of widespread corruption.  In the decades that followed, Police Chief John LaCoste ruled unchecked until the community demanded reform.  We’ve been here before.  And we’ve fought back.

The rights of journalists are under threat, across the country, freedoms we once took for granted are being chipped away.  I took an oath to defend the Constitution and to democratically serve the people of Emeryville.  I’ve had my share of disagreements with Brian Donahue, but this fight isn’t about liking a reporter or not.  It sets a legal precedent that can suppress the information flow of local news coverage stretching beyond Emeryville - and that hurts democracy.  It’s about protecting the right to hold power accountable.  If they can silence him and the Emeryville Tattler, they can silence any voice that challenges the status quo.

This is bigger than Brian Donahue and the Tattler.  It’s about who gets to speak truth to power.  You do.

I know asking for help isn’t easy for any of us and especially for Brian Donahue—it can sometimes feel like an admission of weakness.  But let me remind you: every time you've come to me about an eviction notice, a broken park seat, or a threat to your small business, I show up because asking for help is strength. That’s how we take care of each other. That’s how we win, by being stronger together.

These are our taxpayer dollars, our neighborhoods, our roads and parks.  Emeryville isn’t just buildings. It’s the people who call this city home.

I’m asking you to stand with me and protect what makes Emeryville special.  Show up.  Speak out.  Send your statements of support to priforce@emeryville.org and attend Mr Donahue’s court hearing on May 22, 2025, at 1:30 PM.  Let’s remind those in power that we won’t let journalism—and accountability—be silenced in our city.

Local journalism is about more than headlines. It’s about lifting every voice.

Let’s show this city what we're made of -

In solidarity,

Kalimah Priforce

Councilmember, City of Emeryville

Wednesday, February 12, 2020

The Tattler at Ten

Ten Years of Punching Up

The Tattler Celebrates a Decade of 
Muckraking and Shit Stirring

Ten years ago today three of us started the Emeryville Tattler with a mission.  Concern over a ‘develop at all costs’ juggernaut ensconced at City Hall serving as the impetus, we thought we could flip the City Council and therefore the whole culture in Emeryville politics, ushering in a new era we hoped.  We thought the interests of the residents and average people could be risen up and take precedence over those of the business class and the developers, many of whom had become very chummy with the Council members.  Considering the forces allayed against us, including the then mighty Emeryville Chamber of Commerce, it was pretty audacious of us in retrospect.  But we started up our scrappy little news site nonetheless, knowing we’d make plenty of enemies along the way (and boy, have we).

The idea was as simple as it was brassy.  We thought Emeryville needed a newspaper like our neighboring cities had.  We looked around and seeing the demographic populations of our neighbors with their center-left proclivities, we thought the extreme pro-developer culture at Emeryville City Hall was an anomaly, an accident and therefore not sustainable.  It just needed a little push.  We could see no reason why Emeryville should stand out so starkly among our Bay Area neighbors.  We thought the people here were like the people around us and all we would need to do is to inform them and let democracy take over.  So we did.

While acknowledging there is still work to be done, it is no exaggeration to say Emeryville has indeed flipped.  The former clubby atmosphere at City Hall with developers, businessmen (yes, men) and Council members literally mixing over drinks at the Townhouse or at closed door Chamber functions is bygone.  Our town hall now much more faithfully reflects the resident’s interests.  Emeryville, no longer a throwback curiosity among Bay Area cities, can now be called a leader among them.  We’ll take some small measure of credit here at the truculent little Emeryville Tattler.  The change has been great to be sure but we're still keeping their feet to the fire.

Readers of the above three paragraphs will detect a level of cocksureness if not arrogance.  We don’t deny it.  We always knew we’d have to fight hard to take down the connected wealthy business/developer class and their government sycophants here in Emeryville and we came ready for the fight.  Our pugnacious nature has served us well.  We noted everywhere we looked in this little town, we found rot and we knew we’d have to take on all comers.  And that’s the reputation we cultured.  Our reputation has preceded us. We developed a backchannel cadre of moles who informed us.  That’s how we found out how effective we were being.  There has always been a bit of fear of the Tattler mixed in with the anger in the corporate boardrooms and in government back rooms.

Ten years ago if you had asked us how long our little project would take, we would have guessed about ten years.  We got that right.  Emeryville is now poised to become the town the people here want.  But there are storm clouds all around us.  Senate Bill 330, as of January 1st, the law of the land and the proposed SB 50, stand to take away the democratic autonomy we fought for just as we take our bows.  This new suite of ‘develop at all costs’ laws are coming now not from City Hall, but from Sacramento and they threaten our town much more fundamentally.
We don’t know if the Tattler is ready to take on Sacramento.  We’re audacious, but not that audacious.  Maybe someone else can come in and take over the fight for Emeryville.

In the meantime, we’re going to do a little celebrating.  We celebrate our ten years with selections from the archives.  We’re going to re-post our favorite stories and reader favorites every couple of weeks starting from 2010.

The Tattler is ten!  Our masthead says it all: We're here working for the residents and average people- against those who would take away from the commons.  Looking back, there have been victories and setbacks in that fight.  Reporting on that struggle, it's always easy to see the glass half empty, concentrating on the work yet to be done.  Looking ahead, it's pretty scary.  But ten years on after the Tattler's audacious beginning taking on all comers among the power elite in Emeryville, there's no doubt there have been more victories than setbacks.  We didn't just sit on our duffs and watch our town change around us.  We got involved. And that has served us well.  We feel pretty good about this.