Local Media Elites Parrot the Corporate Line About Sutter
The Community Grassroots Know Better
"People power is the ability of grassroots communities to (1) collective and deliberatively determine the change they want to see, and (2) to make the desired change reality."
-The Activist Handbook
News Analysis
We saw people power in action over the last few months in the community.
Sutter Health Corporation suddenly announced October 30th they had canceled plans to build a major hospital campus at 53rd and Hollis streets in Emeryville, brashly characterizing government environmental regulation as the culprit that sunk the project. The local media were happy to oblige, forwarding the familiar corporate narrative of a rapacious government too cavalier about killing innovation and jobs with onerous regulation. However, the actual reason Sutter abandoned its plans for the Emeryville hospital was primarily as a result of a surprisingly large grassroots campaign of community activism that quickly responded and that appeared from Sutter’s perspective, likely to grow. It was people power that brought down Sutter’s Emeryville hospital plans, not government regulation.
Historically, Emeryville has a well earned reputation for welcoming large scale corporate construction proposals, something acknowledged by Sutter early on as they looked to replace their aging Berkeley facility. Unlike Berkeley or Oakland, in Emeryville, citizen activism has traditionally not been a problem for corporations with big construction plans and that’s been a large part of what corporations see as attractive about Emeryville. It’s generally seen as a place with a compliant government and a complacent citizenry.
At the onset, Sutter saw Emeryville as a near frictionless fit for their planned mega hospital complex and they were taken by surprise by the sudden rise of a whole new citizen group formed specifically to fight the proposed project, Emeryville Neighbors United, joining together with the existing large and powerful North Oakland citizen group, Golden Gate Community Association. Community members were concerned over the scale of the hospital proposal, the 20,000 cars a day the hospital would bring, the danger of the excess traffic to Emery school children on 53rd Street, the daily low flying helicopter flights, Sutter's lack of transparency, the refusal of Sutter to agree to a Community Benefits Agreement, the planned destruction of the Horton Street Bike Boulevard traffic diverter, the 330 foot tower and the general feeling that the city council majority would not have the community's back. So the community took it upon themselves to do the grassroots activism work of making Sutter become a good corporate neighbor or quit.
Right out of the gate, 60 public written comments dropped from the community in response to a required 'Notice of Preparation' environmental document prepared by the City of Emeryville about the proposed hospital. This plus a constant drumbeat about a Community Benefits Agreement the community would force on Sutter made it clear to the healthcare giant the community was energized and the hospital proposal was not going to be a fait accompli.
The rise of local community activism aside, Sutter told the public the reason they changed their mind about building the Emeryville hospital was the fact the project would be regulated by the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), representing what Sutter characterized as a “lack of a clear and predictable regulatory path”. That was something they said they hadn’t planned for. However, any development proposal as large as the Emeryville hospital would be constrained by CEQA.
Sutter said they were promised “relief” from regulation by Sacramento lawmakers including 7th District California State Senator Jesse ArreguĂn. Then, inexplicably, the relief was taken away, leaving Sutter “burdened” by environmental regulations. This is why Sutter publicly says they abandoned their Emeryville plans.
Clarifying the matter at hand, the site Sutter chose to place its hospital is one of the most toxic regulated brownfield sites in the Bay Area. Heavy metals and VOCs contaminate the soil from decades of industrial use. Indeed, the Sutter site is tightly bracketed by the ‘Sherwin Williams Site’ on the south, the ‘Marchant/Whitney Site’ on the west, and the ‘Mound Site’ on the north; all three overseen by the California Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) and cited as among the worst contamination sites in the Bay Area. Groundwater migrates contamination into a giant plume in this part of Emeryville and the actual 12 acre Sutter site, formerly the location of an oil industry R&D, generated its own contamination, adding to the plume.
Given the level of toxic contamination on the site of the proposed hospital combined with the sheer scale of the project, makes it inconceivable that Sutter thought they could get away without environmental review and toxic soil characterization and clean up.The Tattler reached out to Sutter executives Monique Binkley-Smith and Melissa White about the need to examine and clean up the toxic soup under their proposed project but they refused to respond, either on the record or off.
Regarding the relief from regulation Sutter hoped to get, it is noteworthy that of the two Bay Area Sutter proposed hospital sites right now, Emeryville and Santa Clara, only the Emeryville site is a certified toxic brownfields site. Sutter was granted relief from CEQA at their Santa Clara site.
Sutter Health is a large and growing health care corporation. The CEO Warner Thomas received a total compensation package of $11.3 million last year and the corporation reported 2025 total revenues of $19.8 billion and an operating income of $509 million, up significantly from $142 million in 2024. For the first six months of 2026, Sutter reported an operating income of $538 million showing continued upward momentum compared to 2025.
This is not a fly by night operation. Perhaps they hoped the regulators would cut them a break but Sutter knew it would have to pay for environmental oversight at the Emeryville site. Sutter did not get where it is by being reckless with money and it would not have put some tens of millions of dollars into the start up work for the Emeryville site dependent on unlikely but hoped for regulatory relief from CEQA law. Sutter, being a serious corporation, worked environmental regulation into its business plan for the Emeryville project. It is the community activism with all its unpredictability and resultant promises of bad public relations splashed all over the news that spooked them.
Their claims of government regulation killing jobs aside, Sutter itself says community activism for the Emeryville hospital took it by surprise. Three paragraphs down in their ‘Sutter Vitals Statement’ on the ‘East Bay’ press release Sutter calls out community activism as a problem for them: “Community feedback and our continued assessment of changing healthcare needs also helped shape our plans for Emeryville and our broader approach to expanding care across the East Bay”. The local media has not forwarded this admission about community activism from Sutter, settling instead on the traditional Reagan era corporate narrative about government regulation.
Longtime Emeryville resident and Neighbors United founder Tracy Schroth said of the Sutter pull back:
“Sutter says it’s reason for pulling out of Emeryville is the environmental, regulatory burden on them and – I assume – on their bottom line. Good. But funny how they failed to mention the burden it would’ve placed on us, the community, and on our bottom line. Not only would the project damage our quality of life, but as a nonprofit, Sutter would pay nothing, not a dime, in property tax to offset the harm. I like to think that our very vocal objections to the project made a difference. I’m proud of my neighbors for fighting the good fight.”

